I am honored to be a Fiction Reader for the Northern Appalachia Review, where I was born, a Poetry Editor for the Eleventh Hour Literary Review from Binghamton University, one of the places I went to grad school, an Editorial Assistant for The Petigru Review of the South Carolina Writers Association, and a book reviewer for and through The Tupelo Press and published in the Midwest Book Review.
Right now, I am in the middle of reading submissions for two of these publications, and other books appear announced or unannounced. The GIF below is my reaction to things I do not expect.
https://tenor.com/view/god-father-generosity-deserve-gif-14015070
Fiction: For the NAR, we have a specific geographic location. Submitters need not have been born or lived there, or live there currently. When I see something that is not set in the region or has no discernible identification with the region, I stop reading. Below is the map from the website. I think "If you'uns can't read a map, I can't help you 'uns!"
Outside of that, I want to see more than endless dialogue or a narrator rambling on and on. I want to know what people look like, what the locations look like, and some details about what they eat, drink, smoke, wear, etc. In other words, I want a picture.
Poetry: I shudder when I see two or three-word lines, 20 or so lines all jammed together, or prose poetry. Yes, I know about the latter. Poet friends and I have discussed this. To me, such things resemble someone going on and on about something. "Prose Poetry" is an oxymoron in my book. Prose is often poetic; think of Updike, Faulkner, and others.
If prose is put into some poetic format, that turns me off. I want to see poetic features- not necessarily rhyme- but metaphor, simile, inversion of words, and the like. If there is rhyme, I do not want to see words hammered into place.
An example: I recently saw "your desires" paired with "truth's transpires". I shuddered! Not only hammering in rhymes, but a complete misunderstanding of vocabulary.
Am I the Final Authbority on writing? By no means am I open about what I like and what I do not like. If there are three of us reviewing what is submitted, I realize that I can be outvoted. And sometimes I like what I read regardless of the form.
----
My books:
My novel:
https://www.blurb.com/b/10799783-the-botleys-of-beaumont-county